CDTech LCD touch screen

display / touch / bonding solutions

Product and Process Change Notifications in Display Supply: Writing a Clause You Can Enforce

Author: CDTech Publish Time:  Origin:

Change notification clauses are usually written after the first surprise. A batch of modules arrives with a cooler white point, or a panel used for two years is discontinued with a month of supply left, and the quality team finds that the agreement promised only that the supplier would keep the buyer informed. This article deals with the pair of notices a display supplier owes: a product change notification for something that changes, and a product discontinuance notification for something that stops, with a last-time-buy window attached to the second. It sets out the triggers, the clock, the evidence, and clause language to review with counsel. Nothing here is legal advice.

A change you were not told about is a change you cannot price

A change notification clause exists to move a decision earlier. Without one the decision is still made, by the supplier, at a time of the supplier's choosing, and the buyer discovers it in a failed incoming inspection or a customer complaint. By then the changed units are in a warehouse or already fitted to a chassis, and the options have narrowed to containment.

Changes themselves are ordinary. A panel reaches end of life, an LED bin shifts, an adhesive is reformulated, a line moves building. None of that is misconduct. The problem is information asymmetry: the supplier knows the change is coming and can price its effect, and the buyer cannot, because the effect lands on a product the buyer sells. A clause that names triggers, timing and evidence converts that asymmetry into a schedule.

What counts as a change: the trigger list

Trigger lists fail when they are written as categories. A supplier can agree to notify any change affecting form, fit or function and still swap an LED supplier without breaching that promise, because the outline never moved. The list has to name the artefacts.

  • Panel maker, panel revision or grade.
  • Driver IC, controller or firmware timing.
  • LED supplier, bin, or optical film stack.
  • Adhesive, bonding process or cure schedule.
  • FPC, connector, cover glass or touch stack.
  • Production site, line, or a tool rebuilt or moved.
  • A process parameter set outside the control plan.
  • Test method, limit or sampling change.
  • Packaging, labelling or date code format.
  • A sub-supplier change behind any of the above.

The last item carries the most weight, because most changes arrive two tiers down and a list that stops at the supplier's own processes will not catch them. Flow-down is what makes the clause work, and it is the obligation suppliers resist most.

Does a second-source LED require notification

Yes, if the LED is on the controlled characteristic list.

A second source is a material change even when the part number is unchanged. Colour point, luminance and forward voltage all move with the die.

That is the mechanism worth understanding. An LED is binned, and a second source brings a different bin distribution, a different forward-voltage curve and often a different thermal derating. The module may still meet its stated brightness and still look visibly different beside units built last quarter.

Two conditions make a second source routine rather than risky: the buyer has specified a colour point and tolerance tight enough that both sources must meet it, and the supplier holds optical evidence for each source. The notification is still due, because the approved vendor list should record which source shipped.

The harder case is a dual source introduced silently, with the part number unchanged. It is the most common silent change in display supply, precisely because nothing on the paperwork moved.

12.3 inch 1920x720 LCD display with PCAP, optical bonding and AF process
A 12.3 inch 1920x720 LCD display with PCAP, optical bonding and an anti-fingerprint process. A bonded stack multiplies the sub-suppliers whose changes need notice.

Notice period and the clock that starts when

Notice is only meaningful against a start event. A clause that says the supplier will notify as soon as practicable has no clock, and one that starts the clock when the supplier decides to inform someone lets the supplier set the date. The start event should be receipt by a named function, at a named address, of a complete package.

Periods in the industry commonly run from 30 to 90 days depending on the change class, and the number matters less than what it is measured against. Notice must precede the first shipment containing the changed product and leave time for the buyer's requalification to finish. For a change with a long qualification tail, that means the clock starts before implementation.

Two details protect the buyer: name the recipient, so an email to a sales contact does not count, and state that an incomplete package does not start the clock.

Requalification graded by change class

Not every change deserves the same evidence. Grading the classes before a dispute exists tells the supplier what to send and the buyer what to ask for, so neither negotiates a scope while a line waits.

ClassTypical triggersEvidenceBuyer approval
1, minorLabel, packaging, documentationDeclaration and a sampleNotified, no approval
2, moderateLED bin, adhesive, test limitVerification data against specWritten acceptance
3, majorPanel source, site move, new toolRequalification and first articleApproval before shipment

The class should follow the effect rather than the supplier's convenience, and a change touching two classes takes the highest. The AIAG reference set is a useful model for the evidence structure even outside automotive. Power consumption is a class 3 trigger in practice, because it can move a product outside its declared figures under the EU Ecodesign requirements for displays, and a material swap changes the declaration under RoHS.

Deviation and change are different paperwork

A deviation and a change are often filed in the same folder, which is how a deviation becomes permanent without anyone approving it. A deviation, sometimes called a concession, accepts a defined quantity of material that does not meet the specification, for a defined period. A change alters the specification itself.

The paperwork differs because the decision differs. A deviation is a judgement about nonconforming material: how many units, which dates, what the effect is, who carries the risk. A change updates the drawing, the control plan and the approval record, and needs qualification evidence a deviation never carries.

The failure mode is a deviation renewed three times until the nonconforming condition becomes normal, at which point the specification describes a product nobody builds. A clause should limit renewals and require that a second consecutive deviation becomes a change or is rejected.

Drafting the clause: notice, data package, deemed approval

A clause can be short and still do its job if it names four things: what triggers notice, when the clock starts, what the data package contains, and what happens when the buyer does not answer in time.

Supplier shall notify Buyer in writing at least 60 days before the first shipment of any Product containing a change listed in Schedule A. Notice is effective on receipt by Buyer's quality function of a package containing the changed item, the affected part numbers, the before and after condition, the qualification evidence required for that change class, and the proposed first shipment date. Buyer shall respond within 20 working days. Supplier shall not ship Product affected by a Class 3 change before Buyer's written acceptance. Supplier shall flow these obligations to its sub-suppliers.

Deemed approval is the part buyers regret. It keeps supply moving when a review stalls, which is why suppliers ask for it, and it converts the buyer's silence into consent for a change the buyer may not have the evidence to judge. Where it is accepted, exclude class 3 changes and require a complete package before the clock begins. The custom sourcing guide covers where the clause sits among the other terms.

When the notification arrives after the shipment

Sometimes notice arrives with the shipment, or after it. The first question is not who is at fault but what is in the field: which part numbers, which date codes, which customers. Traceability decides whether the response is containment or a recall.

Three actions run in parallel. Quarantine everything identifiable, including supplier stock, material in transit and units in the warehouse. Ask for the change record, evidence and implementation date in writing. And decide each lot: accept under a deviation, rework, or reject, with the cost allocated by the clause.

If product has already reached an end customer, the buyer's own duties arrive. Under the EU General Product Safety Regulation, an economic operator needs traceability and a route to act on a safety issue, and a silent change tests whether both exist.

2.1 inch 480x480 round LCD display with RGB interface
A 2.1 inch 480x480 round LCD display with an RGB interface. Small round modules often carry a single LED string, so a bin change shows across the whole run.

Filing the change in your own drawing and BOM

The supplier's change is only half the record. The buyer's documents describe the part as well, and those are the ones an auditor reads. A drawing revision, a BOM line, an approved vendor entry, an inspection plan and an ERP item revision all have to move together, or the next order buys the old configuration. That is the documented-information discipline the ISO standards portal sets out.

The sequence is straightforward: update the drawing and cite the supplier's change reference, update the BOM and the approved source, revise the inspection plan where the change alters what is tested, and record the acceptance decision. The inspection plan is the step usually skipped.

It is also worth checking where else the part is used, since a change accepted for one product can affect another. The quality and reliability guide covers how incoming and reliability evidence is maintained, and the quality certifications page describes the management system side.

If a change clause is being drafted or renegotiated, start with the trigger list and the clock. CDTech can confirm which changes a custom display module is likely to see and what evidence accompanies each class. Write to [email protected] or use the contact page.

FAQ

Does a second-source LED count as a change?

It should. The part number may not move, but the die, the bin distribution and the forward-voltage curve do, and those determine colour point, brightness and thermal behaviour. Treat it as a material change unless the buyer has specified an optical point tight enough that any compliant source is interchangeable, and even then record which source shipped. The clause works best when the LED appears by name on the controlled characteristic list rather than in a general category.

How much notice is reasonable?

Long enough that the buyer's own qualification finishes before changed units are needed. That depends on the class: a label change needs days, a panel source change with a full reliability sample can need months. Industry practice commonly runs from 30 to 90 days, and the fixed number matters less than the start event and the shipment date it is measured against. Write the period per class and tie it to first shipment, not to implementation.

Can a buyer reject a notified change?

A buyer can refuse to accept changed product, which is a different thing and usually more useful. Rejecting the change outright may be impossible where a component is being discontinued, so the practical rights are to require the evidence, to demand requalification, to refuse shipment before acceptance for major changes, and to exit the part on notice. Where refusal would strand supply, the negotiation moves to price, last-time buy and a transition period rather than to consent.

What is a deviation versus a change?

A deviation accepts a defined quantity of material that does not meet the specification, for a limited period, without altering the specification. A change alters the specification or the process and therefore requires updated drawings, an updated control plan and qualification evidence. The two are often confused because both arrive as a request for approval. The test is simple: if the drawing or the process will be different afterwards, it is a change and needs the full route.

×

Contact Us

(Accept word, pdf, dxf, dwg, jpg, ai, psd file, Max 10M)
captcha

By continuing to use the site you agree to our privacy policy Terms and Conditions.

I agree